Skip to Main Content

Evaluating Sources

How to determine whether a source is popular or scholarly.

Is it Popular or Scholarly?

Sometimes your assignments will require scholarly sources. For other assignments, popular sources may be more appropriate. This guide will compare these two types of sources and provide some tips for using each.
  Scholarly Sources Popular Sources
Audience Written for Professors, Researchers, Subject Experts Written for the general public, people without significant experience or education in the field being written about
Language Typically uses specialized language with a specific definition within a field Written in everyday language that can be generally understood by the average reader
Author Author's credentials (degrees, experience, or institutional affiliation) are listed in the publication May be a journalist/reporter or someone who does not have direct experience working in or studying the field they are writing about
Works Cited Typically includes an extensive bibliography or words cited Generally do not include a bibliography at the end
Original Research Describes original research done by the author(s) Reports on research done by others
Editorial Process Peer-reviewed or refereed by several experts in the field Reviewed by a single editor
Advertisements Rare Frequent advertising
Purpose To share original research findings, to advance understanding of a theory To make a profit, to inform, to entertain, to persuade, etc.

 

Evaluating Resources Video